If you're looking for logic, you're seeing the wrong movie. Siblings David (Toby Maguire) and Jennifer (Reese Witherspoon) are watching TV, and they break the remote control . A strange little man (Don Knotts) shows up with no reason, and pleases himself to transfer David and Jennifer into the black-and-white world of Pleasantville. It is never clear who this old man is and why exactly he's doing this. He's like an avid fan who wants David to share his fantasy, and yet he seems like he's playing God (God said: "Behold, the man has become one of Us, to know good and evil." This guy uses arrows and circles). You'd expect to see everything resolved neatly when the whole thing is over -- but apparently Jennifer doesn't want to return to "her world" at all. And throw common sense out the window too. I find it unbelievable that Jennifer, the rebel and the ne'er do well, becomes studious, intelligent Mary Sue after just a couple of days in Pleasantville. "Bud's" mother and his girlfriend don't question why and how he's come from another world or why he has to leave either. I've also wondered why the movie seems to be a fan of sex, sex, and sex. Somehow, it comes off as advocating the fact that sex will make your life marvelous and wonderful. This idea (unintentionally conveyed, I'm sure...) just does not work well with the subsequently presented messages.
However, the movie is well acted, well directed, and well executed.
It was a visual treat seeing black and white and color together in a
composition, each scene orchestrated so artfully, especially seeing works
of art I don't normally appreciate as much in our "colorful" world.
Throughout the movie, I was kept entertained by the constant flow of food
for thought that I tried to digest continuously, even when the plot itself
slowed down a little (but not much). Maybe flow isn't the right word.
Maybe flood is better. This movie is just rich with underlying meaning --
but it's not hidden under too many layers. You don't have to think too hard,
but you get a lot to think about, if you know what I mean. ;-) And I do love
a movie that presents multiple ideas. In light of the recent Clinton affair
and demand for "family values," it is interesting to see what this movie
has to say. Generally it takes a backseat to individuality and creativity.
Another idea: why do we watch television? Does it make our world
better? Does it make us believe it is better? An interesting scene
occurs when David turns up the volume of the TV when his mother is heard
fighting on the phone. Undoubtedly the subtext that most people will
likely catch on to is the movie's conviction that sticking to one set of
rules is folly, that change is necessary and good. This statement of itself
can also be applied to several different ideas. Pleasantville before change
had occured was peaceful, polite, picturesque, dull, and pallid;
Pleasantville after the change is colorful, riotous, refulgent, dangerous.
These are like two extreme ends of a view: a society where the people has
no voice is oppressive, but there is always the danger when people become
too outspoken riots occur (except here it is brought on by the conservative
side). At first, David is absolutely conservative when he tells Bill
Johnson (Jeff Daniels) that "sometimes you just gotta do your job"; and
Jennifer is the extreme radical who recklessly endangers the universe. By
the end of the movie the two seem to balance each other out and reach a
middle-of-the-road, moderate consensus. The book-burning strongly
reminded me of Holocaust in WWII and the communist revolutions in
Russia and China. A parallel can also be drawn, if one wishes, between
the American Revolution and the insubordinate "coloreds." And let's not
even mention Ku Klux Klan and the civil rights movement of the 60s. Not
a political or theological person? Romanticists will be satisfied that
another idea that is presented is that human beings cannot live without
love or emotion (or sex
On the whole, it's a very easy pill to swallow. And pleasant, too.
"You can't stop something that's inside you."
Rating: B+ (First viewing, 10/23/98)